Henry Fertility (Formerly Reproductive Care of Indiana) — An Honest Editorial Review

For patients searching for reproductive endocrinology care in central Indiana, Henry Fertility — formerly and still legally known as Reproductive Care of Indiana — occupies a distinctive position in the Indianapolis market. Founded and led by Dr. Michael A. Henry, M.D., the practice has operated in the Indianapolis metropolitan area continuously since 1996, making it one of the longer-standing independent fertility clinics in the state. The main office is located in Carmel at 201 Pennsylvania Parkway, Suite 205, just north of Indianapolis, with satellite locations in Terre Haute, Lafayette, Bloomington, Muncie, and Columbus — a geographic footprint that reflects the clinic's commitment to serving patients across Indiana who would otherwise face long drives to a major metropolitan center. With a Google rating of 4.5 stars drawn from more than 219 patient reviews, the practice has built a durable reputation anchored in Dr. Henry's personal approach to care and the consistency of his nursing team. For anyone exploring fertility clinics in Indiana, Henry Fertility is among the first names worth understanding in depth.

Physicians and Clinical Team

Henry Fertility is a physician-led independent practice built around a single founding reproductive endocrinologist supported by an advanced practice provider.

Dr. Michael A. Henry, MD is a board-certified reproductive endocrinologist and infertility specialist who has practiced in Indianapolis since completing his fellowship in 1996. A native of the Indianapolis metropolitan area, Dr. Henry earned his undergraduate degree in biology from Butler University and his medical degree from Indiana University School of Medicine. He completed his OB/GYN residency at Indiana University School of Medicine and then pursued subspecialty fellowship training in Reproductive Endocrinology and Infertility at Rush-Presbyterian-St. Luke's Medical Center in Chicago — one of the historically prominent fellowship programs in the country. He holds dual board certification from the American Board of Obstetrics and Gynecology, with subspecialty certification specifically in Reproductive Endocrinology/Infertility.

Dr. Henry's professional affiliations include the American College of Obstetrics and Gynecology, the American Society for Reproductive Medicine (ASRM), the Society for Reproductive Endocrinology and Infertility (SREI), and the Indiana State Medical Association. He also serves as an Adjunct Clinical Assistant Professor of Obstetrics and Gynecology at Indiana University School of Medicine and as Medical Director of the IU Health IVF Lab — an affiliation that reflects his standing in the regional academic medical community. His stated clinical priorities include honest, compassionate, and personalized care, and patients frequently describe him as unusually approachable for a subspecialist.

Danielle Tat, DNP, FNP-BC is a doctor of nursing practice and board-certified family nurse practitioner who specializes in reproductive health and infertility counseling. She earned her Bachelor of Science in Nursing from Indiana University and her Doctor of Nursing Practice degree from Purdue University. Tat works alongside Dr. Henry in managing the day-to-day care of patients throughout their treatment cycles, and her responsiveness is frequently cited in patient accounts.

Services and Treatments

Henry Fertility offers a full spectrum of reproductive medicine services, from initial evaluation through complex third-party reproduction:

• Fertility Evaluations — Comprehensive diagnostic workups including hormonal assessment, ovarian reserve testing, semen analysis, and structural evaluation of the uterus and fallopian tubes.
• In Vitro Fertilization (IVF) — Performed on-site with the clinic's own IVF laboratory. This is the clinic's primary advanced treatment pathway.
• Intrauterine Insemination (IUI) — A less invasive first-line treatment appropriate for specific diagnoses including mild male factor infertility, cervical factor, and unexplained infertility.
• Intracytoplasmic Sperm Injection (ICSI) — Micromanipulation technique used in conjunction with IVF for male-factor infertility cases.
• Egg Freezing and Fertility Preservation — Oocyte cryopreservation for elective social preservation and for patients facing gonadotoxic medical treatment.
• Donor Egg Program — Established egg donor program for patients with diminished ovarian reserve, poor prior stimulation response, or genetic considerations.
• Donor Sperm Insemination — IUI and IVF cycles using donor sperm, including services for single patients and same-sex female couples.
• Reciprocal IVF — A form of shared biological parenthood available to female same-sex couples, in which one partner provides the eggs and the other carries the pregnancy.
• Gestational Carrier Coordination — Care management for intended parents working with a gestational surrogate.
• Male Infertility Workup — Semen analysis available with or without a physician referral through the clinic's specialty lab.
• Reproductive Surgery — Laparoscopic and hysteroscopic procedures for endometriosis, fibroids, uterine septum, intrauterine adhesions, and tubal reversal.
• Recurrent Pregnancy Loss Evaluation — Systematic diagnostic and management protocol for patients with a history of multiple miscarriages.
• Treatment of Gynecological Conditions — Including menstrual disorders and other conditions affecting reproductive function.

For a detailed overview of the IVF process and what to expect at each stage, see our IVF guide.

Laboratory and Success Rates

Henry Fertility operates an on-site IVF laboratory at its Carmel location. An in-house embryology lab is a meaningful structural feature: it allows the clinic to maintain direct quality control over culture conditions, fertilization monitoring, and embryo development without the logistical complexity of an off-site facility. Dr. Henry's concurrent role as Medical Director of the IU Health IVF Lab underscores a depth of laboratory expertise that distinguishes him from clinicians whose involvement in embryology is less direct.

The clinic reports data to the Society for Assisted Reproductive Technology (SART), and outcomes are independently tabulated and published annually through the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Independently reviewed success rate data for the under-35 age group has shown live birth rates that compare favorably to national benchmarks, though as with all fertility clinics, outcomes vary by patient age, diagnosis, and embryo quality. Prospective patients should review the most current SART and CDC data when making treatment decisions; the CDC's national ART summary is published at cdc.gov/art/artdata. Egg freezing cycles are priced at approximately $10,000 and IVF cycles at approximately $12,300, though individual costs vary and patients should request a detailed fee schedule during consultation.

Patient Experience

Henry Fertility's high Google rating — 4.5 stars across more than 219 reviews — reflects a consistent patient narrative centered on Dr. Henry's accessibility and his willingness to explain complex information plainly. Reviewers across multiple platforms describe him as "very personable, friendly and comforting" and note that he takes time to prepare patients for what to expect during procedures. His nursing team, particularly individual staff members named in patient accounts, is repeatedly cited as responsive and empathetic.

The clinic's satellite office model is a genuine convenience for the significant share of Indiana's population living outside the Indianapolis metro. Rather than routing patients in Bloomington or Lafayette to a single urban location, Henry Fertility has maintained a distributed physical presence across the state — a structural choice that reflects a commitment to access.

Patients considering the clinic should be aware of one operational characteristic documented in multiple reviews: during stimulation cycles, morning monitoring appointments — blood draws and ultrasounds — operate on a first-come, first-served basis with many patients scheduled in the same window. Arriving early is strongly advised to minimize wait times. Some patients also report that appointment time with the physician during active cycles can feel brief. These patterns are common in high-volume reproductive medicine practices, and the nursing staff's availability appears to compensate for physician time constraints in the view of most reviewers.

The clinic emphasizes privacy and discretion as a core practice value, which can be meaningful to patients navigating fertility care in smaller Indiana communities.

Considering At-Home Insemination?

Not every fertility journey begins in a clinic. At-home intracervical insemination (ICI) is a lower-cost, private option that suits patients with no known fertility diagnosis — including single parents by choice, same-sex couples, and people who want to try a few cycles before committing to clinical treatment.

At-home insemination kits like those from MakeAMom come with step-by-step instructions designed for donor or partner sperm. Kits are a one-time purchase that can be reused until conception succeeds, require no clinic visit, and arrive in plain, discreet packaging. Many patients use them as a first step while working toward a fertility consultation — or alongside ovulation tracking while they wait for an appointment slot.

If you have a known fertility diagnosis, have been trying for 12 months without success (six months if you're over 35), or your physician has already recommended IUI or IVF, a board-certified reproductive endocrinologist is the right next step.

Insurance and Financing

Indiana does not have a comprehensive state insurance mandate requiring coverage of IVF or other advanced fertility treatments, which means the majority of patients at Henry Fertility pay for treatment out of pocket unless their employer-sponsored health plan voluntarily includes fertility benefits. The clinic accepts several major insurance plans, including Aetna and Aetna Medicare Advantage, for diagnostic and evaluation services, and staff will file initial consultation visits with insurance where applicable. Patients should verify coverage for specific treatments directly with their insurer before beginning a cycle.

For patients managing out-of-pocket costs, Henry Fertility offers financing options through multiple third-party lenders: Prosper Healthcare Lending, CapexMD, and LendingClub. These programs allow patients to spread treatment costs over time, which can make IVF financially manageable for families who cannot fund a cycle in a single payment. As with any medical financing arrangement, patients should review interest rates and terms carefully before committing.

The clinic's fee estimates — approximately $10,000 for egg freezing and $12,300 for an IVF cycle — are higher than the national median for independent practices, which should be factored into planning. Medication costs are typically additional and can add several thousand dollars to the total. Prospective patients are encouraged to request a comprehensive cost estimate that includes monitoring, laboratory fees, and medication before starting treatment.

Frequently Asked Questions

Who is the physician at Henry Fertility in Indianapolis?

Henry Fertility was founded by and is led by Dr. Michael A. Henry, MD, a board-certified reproductive endocrinologist and infertility specialist. Dr. Henry completed his fellowship in REI at Rush-Presbyterian-St. Luke's Medical Center in Chicago and has practiced in the Indianapolis area since 1996. He also serves as Adjunct Clinical Assistant Professor of OB/GYN at Indiana University School of Medicine and as Medical Director of the IU Health IVF Lab.

What is the relationship between Henry Fertility and Reproductive Care of Indiana?

They are the same practice. The clinic operated for many years under the name Reproductive Care of Indiana and at various points also operated through the domain reprocareindiana.com. The practice has rebranded as Henry Fertility, with the current website at henryfertility.com. Some insurance filings, directory listings, and older records still use the Reproductive Care of Indiana name.

Does Henry Fertility offer care for same-sex couples and LGBTQ+ patients?

Yes. The clinic's third-party reproduction program explicitly includes donor-sperm insemination, reciprocal IVF for female same-sex couples, gestational carrier coordination, and donor egg cycles. These services are available to single patients and LGBTQ+ patients building families.

Does Henry Fertility have locations outside of Indianapolis?

The main office is in Carmel (a northern Indianapolis suburb) at 201 Pennsylvania Parkway, Suite 205. Satellite offices providing care closer to patients are maintained in Terre Haute, Lafayette, Bloomington, Muncie, and Columbus, Indiana. Complex procedures such as egg retrievals and embryo transfers are typically performed at the main Carmel location where the IVF laboratory is housed.